I have just found out a couple of interesting things on the net that might stir up the ‘fake of a fake’ question.
Have a look back in Honda’s past. It developed off road motorcycles in the first place on the back of the Europeans. Off road bikes were either in a class originally called scamblers which then developed into trials. A big player was Spain with a partnership forming Montessa in 1945 which one founder then split off forming Bultaco (I have a 1969 Bultaco Sherpa T). Honda bought out Montessa around 1980, utilising it’s manufacturing and it’s technology after communism had ruined the Spanish industry. Around the same time Honda released it’s famous 2-stroke motocross, the ‘Elsinore’ in the USA.
This bit of history is my attempt to show that the developing Chinese industry is just another page in a book that started in 1869 when French cycle maker Michaux first attached a steam engine to a ‘bone-shaker’ bicycle
Motorcycle brands (not types) are know as ‘marques’ a word which is defined as ‘a license to act as a privateer’. There is no way possible that motorcycle historians can trace all of the marques ever assembled.
It seems that the ‘Thumpstar’ marque was founded in 1999 by a company for the Australian and New Zealand markets. They are primarily manufactured by the Hunan Motor Co. and the Jailing Motor Co. Jailing has been in bed with Honda since 1982. Other companies in China also have collaborative agreements with Honda, sharing manufacturing, assembly and technology.
Check out a USA marque ‘Xtreme’.
http://www.xtrememotorco.com
This company is sourcing its range from the Hunan Motor Co……the same as Thumpstar. Hunan’s own marque is FYM. Is Thumstar a fake FYM…….no.
If it used the marque FYN……you might say so.
When we talk about ‘original’ or ‘fake’ we mean who got the recognisable TM (trademark) first. If Thumpster (with an e) registered first then Thumpstar would be the ‘fake’ I suppose.
Lifan landed in court using the marque ‘Hondga’ after manufacturing and technology were exchanged with Honda. I’d only call Lifans a fake Honda if they had kept the name Hondga.
I think calling a Thumpster a ‘fake’ Thumstar is fair. Or particulary a company even using copied stickers as in the one on the first post I suspect. But you really have to leave it there.
Chinese manufacturing has created a whole new animal….hence the confusion. Modern man often doesn’t see just how dependent he is on labels.
Thumpstar is not making bikes…..they’re ordering with their label and marketing, and they did it earlier than others who are now doing the same. They are obviously getting a range of bikes assembled with some of the best stock bits that China has to offer……but with other marques starting to match the quality of parts selection, it might not be too long before you’re paying the extra just for the name. They’re probably still the best stock Chinese pitbike in Australia that money can buy…….at the moment…..….but don’t get stuck on one page of the history book.