Cactus Jack
Master Spanner Spinner
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2007
- Messages
- 2,690
- Reaction score
- 49
Well basic carbs aren't really designed one way or the other, some more suitable for one or the other, buy design, but basically they all have a choke size, deliver a metered ratio of fuel throughout the throttle range and have a mounting for manifold and filter. Carbs have been getting swapped and adapted from engine to engine through trial and error since time eternal.
From my experience 28mm IS or can be problematic to tune on engines which are not flowing well. Hence I have recommended the average joe stick to 26mm and below. The trial of the above carb on a stock engine I would not normally even attempt but as it turned out I did cause I had nothing else at the time on hand. Also I still wouldn't recommend it unless you use a really good flowing pipe which most don't have. Trial and error as mentioned, is probably the main system used by every engine builder in the world, and this is where you should report your results isn't it?
Yes , we recommend a slightly smaller carb (which is good sound advice) because they give better bottom end throttle response and better lugging power than a bigger carb and the power difference up top is minimal anyway ! Aside from that ~ who rides a stroker motor with the engine at peak revs all the time - the extra few mm of a 28 is only used for a few seconds just before you shift gears and ONLY if you peak rev the engine . In actual fact - the engine can't possibly use anything over 26 mm anyway with a 26 mm manifold and intake port ! IF we tell someone to go for the bigger carb and it bogs and carries on or is too finicky and hard to tune - we're the worst mongrels in the world !!
People can ask ANYONE in the US why they don't use a 28 Mikuni and they'll tell you that they bog and lose power over the VM26's !
Here's an interesting NO BS link on comparisons between vertical 122 to 145 bored Honda engines with different strokes and carb sizes (complete with dyno test and track test results) that some people will find interesting :
http://www.oldrice.com/Powroll_vs_Yosh_125_Shootout_Pop_Cycling.jpg
http://www.oldrice.com/Powroll_vs_Yosh_125_Shootout_Pop_Cycling_2.jpg
http://www.oldrice.com/Powroll_vs_Yosh_125_Shootout_Pop_Cycling_3.jpg
http://www.oldrice.com/Powroll_vs_Yosh_125_Shootout_Pop_Cycling_4.jpg
http://www.oldrice.com/Powroll_vs_Yosh_125_Shootout_Pop_Cycling_5-6.jpg
http://www.oldrice.com/Powroll_vs_Yosh_125_Shootout_Swiss_Opinion.jpg