mattbombers
Senior Member
what is everyone gonna argue about next!?
2012 ......
what is everyone gonna argue about next!?
I think it won't change anything... Be a good moment to shut all you pain in the arses up haha.
SOCCER !!:blah:Geez if this is over.. what is everyone gonna argue about next!?
brad could post the results for the metal testing
and i would bet it would not change a thing everyone
would just say there fake
no matter what brad dose or say most here will
just find something eles to pick at him about
As a new member here, comments like this don't appear to be helpful. Having read this thread with interest and being a braaap owner myself, it is nice to see people challenging claims that still appear to have no validation.
No one at any stage during this thread has rejected something once it's been proven, and there is nothing wrong with asking for proof.
Rather than speculate what would happn when the results are posted up, wouldn't it be worth braaap just putting them on here? After all, braaap themselves have said that they will be posted.
the thread started to go nowhere cause you have been dodging putting up the evidence.
and once again a post with nothing...
Cmon give the guy a break. You don't see anyone else even having metal testing done at all. At least he has tried to appease the masses whether people believe it or not.
And I'm all about building the sport which no one can deny Brapp is trying to do.
I hope you do come on a bit more often Brad. I'm sure some of your info would be very helpful to other Braap riders.
All that stuff is great . but common he could easily put it to rest posting the results or whatever it may be up ?
Rather then keep on beating around the bush and still talking up metal testing in everything he says .
maybe just drop the talk about this "metal testing" on your site in your posts etc... and forget it ever happened... and forget the results ....
either way i wouldn't care ...
Fine then ill post it up for you guys.
The following is a quote directly off the Braaap website.
This is one of the things I’m most proud of, I believe it is one of our biggest points of difference.
The way a bike is made affects everything.
As you know:
We Design the bikes here in Australia, we have a French Engineering Team and Quality Control Crew in China. The bikes are Pre Delivered and the Final Assembling Process is done here in Australia, the mechanics here fill the braaap’s with locktight and grease.
A more in depth run down is on this Video YouTube - Braaap.com.au
A major part of our Manufacturing process is the Metal Testing / Consistency Reporting
What is our METAL TESTING?
Basically we are making sure the materials we use are consistent, that they match up with the Quality we expect and that the material will hold up to the punishment the braaap bikes get put through.
The First Check we do is to make sure that the material we are using has the correct amount of each element.
For example: 6061-T651-CNC is a high Quality material we use.
This material is often found manufactured as aircraft parts etc
The below shows the threshold for each element.
Chemical composition
The alloy composition of 6061 is:
Silicon minimum 0.4%, maximum 0.8% by weight
Iron no minimum, maximum 0.7%
Copper minimum 0.15%, maximum 0.40%
Manganese no minimum, maximum 0.15%
Magnesium minimum 0.8%, maximum 1.2%
Chromium minimum 0.04%, maximum 0.35%
Zinc no minimum, maximum 0.25%
Titanium no minimum, maximum 0.15%
Other elements no more than 0.05% each, 0.15% total
Remainder Aluminum
We have a 3rd party company who do tests on different parts of the bike and send me a report. My Job is to check that our frames are within the threshold.
We also do a test to check the amount of material used for certain parts, let’s use the frame as an example.
The 2 tubes (Twin Spar) on the maestro are a checking point for us. We test the thickness of the tubes to make sure that they are heavy duty enough.
So the 3 main parts that I keep an eye on (the engineers do more)
Whats used in our Material
The Thickness of our Material
The Heat treatment Process
Most people don’t need to understand this side of what we do because if you ask me the most important thing is that the braaap kicks ass on the track, Is a heap of fun, is reliable and that I can have the confidence to say that if there is a manufacturing fault with our product, we will back up our product and fix the problem (No Time Limit, No Expiry on that claim)
I need to be confident in braaap products to be able to say that.
My goal from day 1 has been to help build this sport.
Superlite racing is massive in the USA, my passion has everything to do with superlite riding and racing. I eat, live, breathe and sleep superlite riding.
For us to put everything on the line and spend every day building this sport we need a bike we can trust. That’s why we started building our own bikes.
We have done youth programs, , built riding complex’s, put on FMX shows, promoted race series, and we run VIP days; man we do whatever it takes to push this sport forwards.
I have built four stores in four years so there is a retail presence to support the sport. I am giving it my best shot.
I have done a Video Blog to show you some other info on the braaap metal testing.
Check it out here. YouTube - Metal Testing , braaap manufacturing process
Good on ya Brad.
P.S get the Motard seen up and running. dont worry about the dirt haha
And yeah i read all that, but it still says nothing about his actual report..
unless im reading it wrong he's simply stating the content of 6061 alloy
Its called trade secrets and Itellectual Property.....
I certaintly would not be puplicly handing out the chemical composition of my products and test results.
For me, sailing and the constuction of boats. My boat is made from 125g 5000k pre preg unidirectional carbon that is autoclaved. I'm happy with that... but what I'd love to know is the how many layers, what temp and pressure the autoclave is at and what temp the secondary heat treatment is held at and for how long. Never ever am I going to get that information on paper or over the phone. By handing it over it gives me all the knowledge to go out and build one myself without the RnD. But what I do know is that there is a 2 year warranty and assurance that quality checks are in place.
People need to acept that fact that braaap frames are made and produced using 6061 alloy and there is test done to maintain that consistency the same way Jap cars and bike are produced.
IF you are so interested in finding out wall thickness, heat treatment temps and durations, go and buy a frame and reverse engineer it and post the results. That can't be stopped.
Or try and get the same info out of Kawasaki for thier 450f frame or maybe the chassie of a porsche carrera 911, that you are trying to get out of Brad. I'm sure that the info wont come from that factory, but from someone that has either reverse engineered it or stolen the design and build specs that only manufacturers get to maintain quality and cosistency.
Enter your email address to join: